London Olympics 2012: Badminton cheating by the Chinese is nothing new, Martin Samuel

Don't say I didn't warn you… Badminton cheating by the Chinese is nothing new

|

UPDATED:

21:45 GMT, 1 August 2012

.olympicStats1038148 background:url(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/07_04/bckg308x110.jpg) no-repeat top left; display:block; width:308px; height:110px; padding:0; font-weight:bold
.olympicStats1038148 ul width:98%; padding:2px; list-style:none; position:relative; top:86px; left:6px; font-family:Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
.olympicStats1038148 ul li a padding:0 2px; font-size:11px; color:#0cac0c; text-decoration:none
.olympicStats1038148 a:hover text-decoration:underline
.olympicStats1038148 ul li float:left; list-style-type: none; padding: 0;

LIVE RESULTS |
EVENT SCHEDULE |
MEDALS TABLE

It was earlier this year that the website Badzine published its statistics showing the frequency of walkovers in all-Chinese badminton matches. Chinese players had been scheduled to meet 99 times in 2011: on 20 occasions the game was either not played, or not completed.

When China played China, 19.8 per cent of games did not reach a conclusion. And when China played anyone else The figure dropped to 0.21 per cent. No doubt the Chinese athletes said there was nothing untoward in those figures, too. At these Olympics, this is a line we have been hearing a lot.

It was at this point, however, when the evidence was so overwhelming, that the Badminton World Federation should have felt compelled to act. China were expected to win every gold medal at the London Olympic Games and all reasonable evidence suggested that the athletes and coaches at the pinnacle of the sport were behaving in a nefarious manner. Instead, a blind eye was turned. Today, the reputation of badminton is in tatters.

Named and shamed (clockwise from top left): China's Wang Xiaoli (L) and Yang Yu, South Korea's Jung Kyung Eun (Top) and Kim Ha Na, Indonesia's Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari and South Korea's Ha Jung-eun (L) and Kim Min-jung

Named and shamed (clockwise from top left): China's Wang Xiaoli (L) and Yang Yu, South Korea's Jung Kyung Eun (Top) and Kim Ha Na, Indonesia's Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari and South Korea's Ha Jung-eun (L) and Kim Min-jung

The sport has rightly expelled eight athletes from the Olympic women’s event, but it is too late. Charges will be brought but not all of the culprits are in the dock. Chinese badminton has conspired, literally, in this degradation of sporting contest, tainting rival associations with their behaviour but throughout they have been abetted by those with a duty of care. It is pathetic that the BWF are posturing as men of action now, when for years they have indulged the most obvious cheating.

Ahead of the game

Read Martin's column of February 20

Every bit as blatant, in fact, as what occurred at Wembley Arena on Tuesday night when Chinese second seeds Tian Qing and Zhao Yunlei upset the odds by losing a group game to Danish pair Kamilla Rytter Juhl and Christinna Pedersen.

This placed them in the same half of the knockout draw as Chinese top seeds Wang Xiaoli and Yu Yang, meaning a gold and silver double would be impossible unless Wang and Yang lost, which they then attempted to do. Sensing this their opponents, Jung Kyung-eun and Kim Ha-na of South Korea, tried to lose too, but failed. Then the next pairs, from South Korea and Indonesia, played to get beat. A very genteel crowd turned ugly and with good reason. Far from justifying the cost of the tickets and the trip, this occasion was worthless, bankrupt.

Caught out: An official speaks to players from China and South Korea

Caught out: An official speaks to players from China and South Korea

The shuttlers had become throwers and in doing so had cheated everybody. The sport, the Olympic ideal, their fellow athletes, but most scurrilously, the fans. The athletes’ Olympic oath, read at the opening ceremony, is a little woolly on fixing, although it would be hard to argue that what occurred at Wembley Arena was in ‘the true spirit of sportsmanship, for the glory of sport and the honour of our teams’. The regulations of the BWF are more specific, however. Rule 4.5 deliberately outlaws ‘not using one’s best efforts to win’ in a list of offences worthy of fierce sanction. A pity nobody thought to apply the rulebook before the Olympics were besmirched, and three pairs led astray by China’s manipulation.

Indeed, spare a little thought for six of the banned, at least. Jung and Kim, plus Ha Jung-eun and Kim Min Jung of South Korea, and Indonesian pair Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari. What they did was wrong, but they were only responding to the action of the Chinese. If they had done their best, the Chinese would have got away with schedule arrangement, as they have done for years.

Wise before the event: Chris Adcock spoke out earlier this year

Wise before the event: Chris Adcock spoke out earlier this year

Chris Adcock of Great Britain spoke out against match-fixing earlier this year. ‘The statistics speak for themselves,’ he said. ‘With the depth China has, they can sway and manipulate matches to their advantage. Some matches you watch are clearly thrown. Unfortunately it is now part of the game but in Olympic year it’s not what the sport is about and it is up to the rest of the world to stop it.’

And what happened Nothing.

A year ago, the BWF began to monitor same-country draws, yet no penalties were issued and no irregularities discovered.This latest development, beneath the gaze of the world at the most high-profile sporting competition in the world, is a public humiliation: but no more than the sport deserves. Anything that is not stopped is encouraged and the officials at the top of badminton have been letting the cheats win for too long.

London 2012 Olympics: Badminton: Eight badminton players disqualified

Booted out! All eight badminton fixers disqualified from Games

|

UPDATED:

12:13 GMT, 1 August 2012

.olympicStats1038148 background:url(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/07_04/bckg308x110.jpg) no-repeat top left; display:block; width:308px; height:110px; padding:0; font-weight:bold
.olympicStats1038148 ul width:98%; padding:2px; list-style:none; position:relative; top:86px; left:6px; font-family:Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
.olympicStats1038148 ul li a padding:0 2px; font-size:11px; color:#0cac0c; text-decoration:none
.olympicStats1038148 a:hover text-decoration:underline
.olympicStats1038148 ul li float:left; list-style-type: none; padding: 0;

LIVE RESULTS |
EVENT SCHEDULE |
MEDALS TABLE

The eight badminton players at the centre of allegations of throwing matches in the women's doubles have been disqualified from the Olympics.

Former British badminton star Gail Emms earlier led calls for the four women's pairs to be kicked out of the Games after a series of deliberate attempts to lose their matches.

She also claimed the referee had been warned before the matches that something 'dodgy' could happen, but the concerns were dismissed.

Controversy: Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari of Indonesia and Jung Eun Ha and Min Jung Kim of Korea are threatened with a 'black card'

Controversy: Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari of Indonesia and Jung Eun Ha and Min Jung Kim of Korea are threatened with a 'black card'

In scenes of farce at Wembley Arena on Tuesday evening, the top seeds from China, two from South Korea and another from Indonesia seemed to want to lose in an attempt to manipulate the draw.

A hearing was held this morning, and all of the athletes involved have since been banned for their part in the scandal.

All eight players had been charged by the Badminton World Federation/BWF with 'not using one's best efforts to win a match' and 'conducting oneself in a manner that is clearly abusive or detrimental to the sport'.

Emms, who won Olympic silver with Nathan Robertson in the mixed doubles in Athens in 2004, was outraged by the conduct and told BBC Radio Five Live: 'This is the Olympic Games, if badminton wants to save face I personally feel they should disqualify the four pairs and re-instate the pairs who came third and fourth in the group and then have a better competition.

'You cannot do this in an Olympic Games, this is something that is not acceptable and it just makes not only our sport but the organisers and the poor crowd who had to watch, who pay good money to watch two matches….it was just disgraceful, absolutely disgraceful.

'I would disqualify them.'

More to follow.

Not amused: Gail Emms has called for the fixers to be disqualified

Not amused: Gail Emms has called for the fixers to be disqualified


Farce: Wang Xiaoli (right) and Yu Yang (left) wanted to avoid playing their compatriots

Farce: Wang Xiaoli (right) and Yu Yang (left) wanted to avoid playing their compatriots


Victors: Kim Ha Na (left) and Jung Kyung Eun (right) eventually won, despite their best efforts

Victors: Kim Ha-na (left) and Jung Kyung-eun (right) eventually won, despite their best efforts


Heated: A coach for Indonesia argues with a court official

Heated: A coach for Indonesia argues with the tournament referee

London 2012 Olympics: Gail Emms calls for Badminton fixers to be kicked out of Games

Kick them out! Former star Emms calls for Badminton's fixers to be disqualified

|

UPDATED:

08:48 GMT, 1 August 2012

.olympicStats1038148 background:url(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/07_04/bckg308x110.jpg) no-repeat top left; display:block; width:308px; height:110px; padding:0; font-weight:bold
.olympicStats1038148 ul width:98%; padding:2px; list-style:none; position:relative; top:86px; left:6px; font-family:Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
.olympicStats1038148 ul li a padding:0 2px; font-size:11px; color:#0cac0c; text-decoration:none
.olympicStats1038148 a:hover text-decoration:underline
.olympicStats1038148 ul li float:left; list-style-type: none; padding: 0;

LIVE RESULTS |
EVENT SCHEDULE |
MEDALS TABLE

Former British badminton star Gail Emms has called for the four women's pairs who apparently tried to throw matches on Tuesday night to be disqualified from the Olympics.

She also claimed the referee had been warned before the matches that something 'dodgy' could happen, but the concerns were dismissed.

In scenes of farce at Wembley Arena on Tuesday evening, a pair from China, two from South Korea and another from Indonesia seemed to want to lose in an attempt to manipulate the draw.

Controversy: Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari of Indonesia and Jung Eun Ha and Min Jung Kim of Korea are threatened with a 'black card'

Controversy: Greysia Polii and Meiliana Jauhari of Indonesia and Jung Eun Ha and Min Jung Kim of Korea are threatened with a 'black card'

The Badminton World Federation confirmed that all four pairs would face charges of 'not using one's best efforts to win a match' and 'conducting oneself in a manner that is clearly abusive or detrimental to the sport'.

A hearing will be held later on Wednesday morning with a decision due to be announced in due course.

But Emms, who won Olympic silver with Nathan Robertson in the mixed doubles in Athens in 2004, told BBC Radio Five Live: 'This is the Olympic Games, if badminton wants to save face I personally feel they should disqualify the four pairs and re-instate the pairs who came third and fourth in the group and then have a better competition.

'You cannot do this in an Olympic Games, this is something that is not acceptable and it just makes not only our sport but the organisers and the poor crowd who had to watch, who pay good money to watch two matches….it was just disgraceful, absolutely disgraceful.

Not amused: Gail Emms has called for the fixers to be disqualified

Not amused: Gail Emms has called for the fixers to be disqualified

'I would disqualify them.'

All four pairs had already qualified for the last eight meaning the only issues at stake were the final placings in the first-round group stage.

The fiasco began when Chinese top seeds Wang Xiaoli and Yu Yang started to show little interest in beating Koreans Jung Kyung-eun and Kim Ha-na to finish top of Group A.

Coming second would have meant avoiding compatriots and second seeds Tian Qing and Zhao Yunlei at least until the final.

Tian and Zhao had been sent off their natural path to the final as second seeds by defeat to Denmark's Kamilla Rytter Juhl and Christinna Pedersen earlier in the day.

Farce: Wang Xiaoli (right) and Yu Yang (left) wanted to avoid playing their compatriots

Farce: Wang Xiaoli (right) and Yu Yang (left) wanted to avoid playing their compatriots

The Koreans responded to China's antics by copying them and referee Thorsten Berg emerged to warn all the players.

The match restarted and the Koreans went on to win 21-14 21-11. The startling statistic revealed the longest rally in the first game had been just four strokes.

The matter did not end there as a second Korean pair, the third seeds Ha Jung-eun and Kim Min-jung, then attempted to engineer defeat in their match against Indonesia's Meiliana Jauhari and Greysia Polii.

Their motive was apparent retaliation to avoid Wang and Yu in the quarter-finals, an outcome they failed to achieve as they eventually won 18-21 21-14 21-12.

Victors: Kim Ha Na (left) and Jung Kyung Eun (right) eventually won, despite their best efforts

Victors: Kim Ha-na (left) and Jung Kyung-eun (right) eventually won, despite their best efforts

The Indonesians were not bystanders in the affair either as they responded to the Koreans by trying to lose themselves.

With the crowd getting increasingly restless, Berg again intervened and brandished the black card to disqualify the players.

He quickly rescinded his decision on protest but returned courtside, despite an attempt to restrain him by the Indonesia coach, as the histrionics – now including time-wasting – continued.

Emms also claimed that the referee was warned about the potential for a situation developing in the evening session earlier in the day but dismissed any concerns.

'This point was raised in the lunchtime manager's meeting,' she said. “All the managers got together with the referee and said, 'look, this has happened, in Group D you will find some very dodgy matches going on in the evening because of it' and the referee laughed and said 'oh don't be silly'.

Heated: A coach for Indonesia argues with a court official

Heated: A coach for Indonesia argues with the tournament referee

'And the managers said 'we know the game, we know the players and we know the teams and we know this is going to happen.'

She added: 'Badminton, in the Olympics and in all tournaments across the circuit, it's never played in a group stage, it's always a straight knockout system and for some reason they decided that the Olympic Games in 2012 should be this group stages.

'And as soon as heard that I went 'it's going to bring up match fixing', that was my first thought, and lo and behold last night that is exactly what happened.'