Steve Kean was a dead man walking – Michael Walker on the road

Kean a dead man walking – away from the madness

By
Michael Walker

PUBLISHED:

21:00 GMT, 30 September 2012

|

UPDATED:

21:00 GMT, 30 September 2012

The call they had been expecting for months came as a surprise. The players of Blackburn Rovers were midway through their evening meal on Friday at the team’s hotel when they were informed that knives and forks had to be put down, that then-manager Steve Kean wanted to speak to them.

‘We knew something was wrong,’ explained the young Rovers midfielder Jason Lowe.

‘We were halfway through our dinner when the team meeting was called. Then we had an idea. It wasn’t very nice – a horrible way to do it.’

Dead man walking: Steve Kean had been on borrowed time at Blackburn

Dead man walking: Steve Kean had been on borrowed time at Blackburn

Kean told the Blackburn players that, after almost two years in position at Ewood Park, if not in charge, he was no longer their manager. In a later statement, Kean used the word ‘untenable’.

Eric Black, Kean’s assistant, took on the caretaker role that used to be Tony Parkes’ domain at Ewood and Black said: ‘Steve wanted to speak to everybody at the same time. It was a sombre atmosphere. The players were disappointed. They all shook his hand.’

Black had to pick a team for Saturday’s game at Charlton, which may well have been the same one that Kean would have selected.

Black, 49 on Monday, has managed Motherwell and Coventry and did not rule himself out of the Blackburn job, but one imagines he is considered too close to Kean by the hierarchy and supporters to be a contender.

Besides, Black has seen Blackburn from the inside and, however messy it appears from afar, you can bet it will look worse from within.

All square: Blackburn couldn't hold on to their lead at Charlton

All square: Blackburn couldn't hold on to their lead at Charlton

‘I’ve seen things which I didn’t think I would see,’ said Black. ‘I won’t elaborate. It’s the crazy world of football.’

Gael Givet, for example, did not reappear for the second half against Charlton. Givet looked irritated as he walked towards the tunnel at half-time, removing his shirt.

Black was asked if Givet, who suffered heart palpitations last season, had an injury.

‘No,’ replied Black. ‘It wasn’t an injury.’ Was it a tactical decision ‘No, it wasn’t a tactical decision.’

Hmmm.

Lowe spoke of the ‘great spirit brewing in that dressing room’ and there was no lack of commitment in a most average match. But it would be no shock to discover that, with the influx of nationalities and signings (some not made by Kean), there are divisions.

Shebby Singh, Blackburn’s ‘global advisor’ as appointed by the Venky’s ownership, was at the Valley to see Dickson Etuhu give Rovers the lead and Johnnie Jackson’s home equaliser. Singh was thought to be seeking a meeting with Black on Sunday.

Mystery: Givet (left) storms off at half-time shadowed by Black (right)

Mystery: Givet (left) storms off at half-time shadowed by Black (right)

It may well have entailed confirmation that Black will be in charge for Wednesday’s trip to Nottingham Forest because, unless Tim Sherwood resigns from his coaching job at Tottenham, getting the former Rovers captain from White Hart Lane may take time. If Spurs chairman Daniel Levy gets his way, it may also take money.

But Sherwood is a solid favourite to be Blackburn’s fourth manager since Mark Hughes left in 2008. It is thought he wants the job and it is now about getting matters across the line. On Sunday, as is the way of things, Sherwood played it down. ‘Just rumours,’ he said.

In the meantime, the club have been inundated with applications. Dozens apparently, from all across the continent, including from former Chelsea full back Albert Ferrer, who had a one-season stint as manager of Vitesse Arnhem.

Italian Silvio Baldini, last seen at Vicenza in Serie B, is another believed to have expressed an interest. Then there is Mick McCarthy, experienced and available. Craig Short, briefly manager of Notts County, had six years as a player at Ewood and has been mentioned. As has Alan Shearer.

In contention: Shearer (left) has been mooted as a potential replacement for Kean

In contention: Shearer (left) has been mooted as a potential replacement for Kean

Shearer would certainly fit the ‘global’ aspect of Singh’s remit. He, like Sherwood, would also spark a local reaction and sell tickets. Rovers have had only one Saturday home game this season and there were 14,000 to see Leicester.

On Saturday Wolves are the visitors. The last time Rovers and Wolves met at this level on a Saturday, in November 2000, there were 20,380 present.
Crowds above 20,000 would show how many have stayed away during Kean’s sour era. It was his 45th birthday on Sunday. By doing what he did on Friday night, at least Kean was spared shaking hands with the referee at Charlton, Darren Deadman.

What about fans' abuse

Charlton Athletic have a warm, family reputation and there was a happy-clappy, half-time greeting for former player Allan Simonsen, the former European Footballer of the Year who somehow left Barcelona for Charlton in 1982 – arguably the strangest transfer in history.

Simonsen’s reception contrasted with that of another former player, Danny Murphy. Blackburn’s Murphy had 18 months at Charlton in between his Liverpool and Tottenham phases.

It is hard to imagine Murphy being awful at Charlton and yet the abuse he received on Saturday was just that. It was personal and, while some of the abusers might say it was ‘banter’, Murphy cannot have heard it that way.

Footballers are lectured about their behaviour; what about the fans

Andy Carroll would not have imagined leaving Liverpool – Mersey Beat

Carroll would never have imagined this after strong Euros

|

UPDATED:

14:26 GMT, 20 July 2012

Fantasy football 2012

It should be so different. After finishing last season with a surge, then acquitting himself well at Euro 2012, Andy Carroll would have envisaged reporting back for pre-season training with a spring in his step and a glint in his eye.

Instead, Carroll will cross the Atlantic this weekend harbouring insecurities and a degree of frustration that the writing appears to be on the wall for his time on Merseyside: any club willing to meet Liverpool’s 20million valuation will be able to buy the England striker.

Unforeseen: Andy Carroll returns to a bleak Liverpool future

Unforeseen: Andy Carroll returns to a bleak Liverpool future

More from Dominic King…

Mersey Beat: All change at Liverpool but Shankly tradition must remain
18/05/12

Mersey Beat: Andy Carroll from zero to hero – times have changed for Liverpool No 9
11/05/12

Mersey Beat: Why Aquilani's Anfield return would not be the worst outcome for Liverpool
27/04/12

Mersey Beat: The return of Roy Hodgson – but what reception can he expect
20/04/12

Mersey Beat: The knives are out, but King Kenny must be afforded more time at Liverpool
30/03/12

Mersey Beat: Rodwell needs a slice of luck to realise his undoubted potential… and it must happen soon
23/03/12

Meresy Beat: Liverpool must build on derby delight to bring REAL glory nights back to Anfield
16/03/12

Mersey Beat: As Moyes marks 10 years in the job, Everton must cherish his every extra moment in charge
09/03/12

VIEW FULL ARCHIVE

Inevitably, the indications that
Liverpool are ready to let Carroll go just 19 months, 56 appearances and
11 goals after his 35million move from Newcastle has caused a huge
stir around the red half of the city and the majority believe he at
least deserves an opportunity to shine for Brendan Rodgers.

Rodgers, who has made a huge impression on the Liverpool players he has worked with during his first few weeks at the helm, has a vision in mind for how he wants his side to play, rat-a-tat-tat passing and pressing to torment the opposition.

From the signings he has made and is attempting to make, it is clear to see who will slot into which holes in his preferred 4-3-3 formation. The engine room should contain Steven Gerrard, Lucas and one other from a group including, among others, Joe Cole, Jordan Henderson and Charlie Adam.

Leading the attack will be Luis Suarez and he will be flanked by Fabio Borini and Stewart Downing. Clint Dempsey would obviously feature if Liverpool’s attempts to pluck him from Fulham are successful, while Craig Bellamy will also feature if remains at Anfield.

Where, then, would Carroll fit in If he is only going to figure sporadically, then Rodgers is being fair to the player. If he can’t promise him regular football – which Carroll needs to be at his best – then honesty is the best policy and Liverpool have to protect their investment.

Calling the shots: Brendan Rodgers does not need the striker

Calling the shots: Brendan Rodgers does not need the striker

The thing is, though, Carroll has done
more than hint that he is ready to make a difference in a Red shirt and
who is to say he couldn’t fit into a front three anyway Would it not be
possible for him to play centrally with Suarez, who loves cutting in
off the flanks, and Borini peeling off him

It is sometimes easy to forget that Carroll is only 23 and if Liverpool do offload him, to Newcastle, West Ham or Aston Villa, they would be ushering out the door a player who has yet to fulfil his potential. Some would say it is brave. Others would label it a gamble.

Liverpool’s recent history is littered with big money forwards who have flopped – Robbie Keane, El Hadji Diouf, Djbiril Cisse and Ryan Babel underwhelmed at a grand total of 55million – but Carroll, for all the difficulties he endured, is not someone The Kop want to give up on.

‘I’ve spoken openly and honestly with Andy in terms of where he is at, but I have done the same with all of the players – I have spoken to all of them,’ said Rodgers, who will be in the dugout for the first time on Saturday as Liverpool manager against FC Toronto.

Options: Carroll could work nicely in a front three

Options: Carroll could work nicely in a front three

‘It gets highlighted more with Andy because he is a young player. Maybe others may not see him fitting in with me, but for me he is an important part of the group. There is talk of him going on loan, but there is absolutely no way I would be looking to loan a player like that.

‘But his condition will be the same as every player. If an offer comes in for any player at the club we would either look at it – or dismiss it – and Andy’s no different to that.’

Listening to the impressive Rodgers speak, he is adamant that only a few tweaks are needed to make Liverpool competitive again in the future. Whether that future contains Andy Carroll remains to be seen.

Mersey Beat: Bill Shankly tradition must remain at Liverpool

All change at Liverpool but Shankly tradition must remain

|

UPDATED:

14:45 GMT, 18 May 2012

Of all the famous one-liners that Bill Shankly delivered in his own inimitable way, there is one that stands head and shoulders above the rest: 'Liverpool Football Club exists to win trophies.'

The long-held tradition at Anfield was to go gathering cups in May, whether it was the League Championship, an FA Cup or one of those sparkling European gongs.

First was first according Shankly, to the most significant figure in Liverpool's history. Anything else was failure.

Prize guy: Bill Shankly lifted plenty of trophies as Liverpool manager

Prize guy: Bill Shankly lifted plenty of trophies as Liverpool manager

More from Dominic King…

Mersey Beat: Andy Carroll from zero to hero – times have changed for Liverpool No 9
11/05/12

Mersey Beat: Why Aquilani's Anfield return would not be the worst outcome for Liverpool
27/04/12

Mersey Beat: The return of Roy Hodgson – but what reception can he expect
20/04/12

Mersey Beat: The knives are out, but King Kenny must be afforded more time at Liverpool
30/03/12

Mersey Beat: Rodwell needs a slice of luck to realise his undoubted potential… and it must happen soon
23/03/12

Meresy Beat: Liverpool must build on derby delight to bring REAL glory nights back to Anfield
16/03/12

Mersey Beat: As Moyes marks 10 years in the job, Everton must cherish his every extra moment in charge
09/03/12

Mersey Beat: The pursuit of another landmark… but will Gerrard reach 100 caps
02/03/12

VIEW FULL ARCHIVE

It was a simple maxim but it was one that served the club well during their era of dominance in the 1970s and 1980s.

The thought of finishing fourth was never entertained and it was certainly not something that would ever have been celebrated.

Times, however, change and the events of the past few days have shown that Liverpool which moves forward under Fenway Sports Group will be dramatically different to the one of the past.

Winning trophies, it would appear, is no longer enough.

'The Carling Cup and the FA Cup don't generate the revenue and the success that is needed to keep investing,' Liverpool managing director Ian Ayre explained.

'If you want to be successful, you have got to keep investing. People don't want to hear that football is a business. They don't.

'They want to see us put lots of money into the team and win lots of trophies and games. But you have got to have both. If you don't do well in the league and don't get into the Champions League, you are writing cheques from your own pocket. That is not a sustainable way going forward.'

Ayre's point is clear. Fenway Sports Group do not have the same spending power of, say, Manchester City, Chelsea and Manchester United but they want to be competing with those clubs on a regular basis going forward.

Kenny Dalglish was jettisoned because Liverpool's performance in the Barclays Premier League was unacceptable over the last 12 months and finishing eighth with 52 points was not what John W Henry and Tom Werner envisaged when they bankrolled last summer's transfers.

The good: Kenny Dalglish got his hands on the Carling Cup in February

The good: Kenny Dalglish got his hands on the Carling Cup in February

The bad: Dalglish's Liverpool side struggled in the Premier League

The bad: Dalglish's Liverpool side struggled in the Premier League

But, in years to come, what will resonate more in the minds of supporters when they look back on the 2011-12 campaign

The disappointment of home draws against Swansea, Norwich and Aston Villa or the dramatic afternoon at Wembley when Liverpool won the Carling Cup

'I understand there is a balance for the club financially,' said Liverpool skipper Steven Gerrard in January.

'I understand that being in the top four is massive. But I don't want to say I finished in the top four five times. I want to look back and say I won the Carling Cup three, four or five times.'

Joe Cole, currently on loan at Lille, offered a similar view in the build-up to Liverpool's FA Cup final clash with his old employers Chelsea.

'Everyone talks about the Champions League these days,' he said. 'But what are you going to tell your grandkids about in the future The days that you played in low key group games around Europe or the days that you celebrated winning a cup at Wembley'

Nowhere to hide: Liverpool were left stunned as Norwich won a point at Anfield

Nowhere to hide: Liverpool were left stunned as Norwich won a point at Anfield

Making relentless progress whilst adhering to old traditions is almost impossible to do in sport but FSG have shown they can blend those two elements, given all they have achieved with the Boston Red Sox and Fenway Park.

But to propel Liverpool forward, they have no option but to be sensitive to the past.

Liverpool resonates with players at home and abroad because of trophy winning exploits and many fans will continue to wonder why Dalglish was not given another opportunity to build.

'There is not a Liverpool fan on the planet who does not want to see this football club in the Champions League and winning it,' Ayre explained.

Next in line Liverpool were granted permission to speak to Roberto Martinez

Next in line Liverpool were granted permission to speak to Roberto Martinez

'The way to get back into it is by winning in the league. It's great that we have got back into Europe through winning the Carling Cup.

'But (finishing in) eighth place We were 37 points off the winners (Manchester City), 17 points off fourth place and had 14 losses. (Whether Dalglish stayed) was never about an individual result – and rightly so. It was always about taking a review of the stock of the season in full.'

The season is not the only thing the FSG need to take stock on.

The Champions League may be required for finance and while Liverpool need to be competing in that competition, it is vital they continue to win trophies.

Shankly's days are gone but his philosophy remains as relevant as ever.

Mersey Beat: Andy Carroll from zero to hero

Andy Carroll from zero to hero – times have changed for Liverpool No 9

|

UPDATED:

13:40 GMT, 11 May 2012

It was last Boxing Day when it appeared the game might be up for Andy Carroll.

Liverpool had been held to a frustrating 1-1 draw by Blackburn Rovers and their 35million striker had, to put it mildly, underwhelmed.

Carroll had started only two of Liverpool's previous eight matches in the Barclays Premier League and had not scored since October 29 but all hopes that he would engage in some target practice against basement side Blackburn evaporated.

On the up: Andy Carroll has rediscovered his form for Liverpool

On the up: Andy Carroll has rediscovered his form for Liverpool

More from Dominic King…

Mersey Beat: Why Aquilani's Anfield return would not be the worst outcome for Liverpool
27/04/12

Mersey Beat: The return of Roy Hodgson – but what reception can he expect
20/04/12

Mersey Beat: The knives are out, but King Kenny must be afforded more time at Liverpool
30/03/12

Mersey Beat: Rodwell needs a slice of luck to realise his undoubted potential… and it must happen soon
23/03/12

Meresy Beat: Liverpool must build on derby delight to bring REAL glory nights back to Anfield
16/03/12

Mersey Beat: As Moyes marks 10 years in the job, Everton must cherish his every extra moment in charge
09/03/12

Mersey Beat: The pursuit of another landmark… but will Gerrard reach 100 caps
02/03/12

Mersey Beat: For Everton fans, promising Van der Meyde will be the player who failed to deliver
24/02/12

VIEW FULL ARCHIVE

He ran up blind alleys, drifted into positions where he never threatened to make an impact and was so far out of sync with his strike partner Luis Suarez that many walked away from Anfield that night thinking Carroll would never flourish in a Reds shirt.

Given his dispiriting efforts occurred days before the transfer window opened, it was inevitable he ended up being linked with transfers elsewhere.

A return to Newcastle was mooted, Aston Villa and Tottenham were mentioned, but the thought of him flourishing in red was remote.

Now look at him. After terrorising John Terry twice in the space of 72 hours, Carroll is being put forward as a potential member of England's Euro 2012 squad and his performances have improved to such an extent that his critics have hastily re-evaluated their judgements.

From expensive misfit to striker of enormous potential, Carroll's encouraging finish to the campaign has offered real hope that, come next season, he will be doing what all Liverpool No 9s are supposed to do – scoring goals with monotonous regularity.

So what has changed

In a nutshell, he strips significantly fitter than he was at Christmas and has been imbued with confidence.

Carroll is a player who benefits from huge amounts of work and the spin-off of him having more start in 2012 is that he is stronger and more effective.

Testing times: Carroll had failed to live up to his billing for much of the campaign

Testing times: Carroll had failed to live up to his billing for much of the campaign

There has been a noticeable improvement in the way Carroll has been training and he looks content with his lot on Merseyside, preferring the quiet life at home with his girlfriend, Stacey, than being a regular on the city's nightclub scene.

He has been making important contributions since the end of January – his towering flick on to Dirk Kuyt created the winner against Manchester United in the FA Cup tie – and the statistics show how much of an influence he is having.

Carroll has been named as substitute 10 times since New Year's Day; of the games he has started on the bench, Liverpool have lost six – including the FA Cup final – and drawn three, with their sole victory coming against League One side Oldham in the FA Cup third round.

True, his critics will argue that some other statistics paint a different picture – he has only scored four goals in the Barclays Premier League this season and created another two.

In the cups, he scored five times and a tally of nine strikes in 46 appearances is not outstanding ratio for a striker.

Dream team: Carroll is tipped to form a productive partnership with Luis Suarez

Dream team: Carroll is tipped to form a productive partnership with Luis Suarez

'All the stats prove that strikers, especially target strikers, peak when they are 26,' said Liverpool's former director of football Damien Comolli.

'He is 23. He has got so much more to come. It is incredible. He is intelligent, he is dedicated, he listens, and he has got a good lifestyle.

'I don't see why he shouldn't be a big success. He is a much better player technically. I think his runs are better, he is very, very fit, and his lifestyle is very good.

'All the time I was at Liverpool and he was at Liverpool he was never caught drinking or doing stupid things. He looks after himself. Slowly but surely the perception of Carroll has changed.

'There is now genuine excitement about what he and Suarez may do next season and the talk that he may be a significant summer casualty has started to evaporate.'

'Carroll has to be a key part of this Liverpool team going forward,' said former Liverpool forward John Aldridge earlier this week.

'He can dominate defences and scare the living daylight out of them. I've been on his case but the real Andy Carroll has shown he belongs at Anfield.'

How different that statement sounds to the ones that were being made on Boxing Day.

John W Henry shows brutal side

Henry shows brutal side as he swings axe just hours after genteel lunch with Comolli

|

UPDATED:

21:51 GMT, 12 April 2012

‘Damien has been terrific. No one has worked harder over the past year. His accomplishments thus far have been extremely important. He has organised so much, so quickly and so well.’ – John W Henry, Nov 10 2011

How quickly and ruthlessly things can change. When Liverpool’s principal owner offered that glowing appraisal, six days after Comolli had celebrated the first anniversary of being installed as director of football, it was impossible to think he would not see out a second year.

Liverpool were sixth in the Barclays Premier League, seven points behind second-placed Manchester United, and Henry’s very public backing showed the Americans were confident the Frenchman would make their ‘moneyball’ vision work.

Brutal: Henry (left) axed Comolli on Thursday

Brutal: Henry (left) axed Comolli on Thursday

Here was a man to crunch statistics, unearth bright young prospects and deliver success within a reasonable budget.

What the last 24 hours have shown is how swiftly, coldly and decisively Fenway Sports Group would act if they felt their investment was in jeopardy. This was Anfield’s Night of the Long Knives. For Operation Hummingbird, read Operation Liver Bird.

Comolli had arrived at Liverpool’s training base on Wednesday morning without any sense that his position was in grave danger. He spoke enthusiastically about the previous night’s win at Blackburn and how the doughty performance demonstrated that the club’s current league position was false.

He reeled off an impressive array of stats about how many times Liverpool had hit the post this year and was in high spirits. His schedule was filled with meetings over the club’s summer transfer priorities – a central defender and a striker.

Even after having lunch with Henry and Liverpool chairman Tom Werner, there was nothing to suggest he was on the verge of unemployment. The first he knew of it was when he was summoned to a plush hotel on the city’s waterfront, late on Wednesday evening.

Struggling: Liverpool have flattered to deceive this season

Struggling: Liverpool have flattered to deceive this season

Swiftly, brutally, Comolli became the scapegoat for the unravelling of Liverpool’s Champions League ambitions, the man who carried the can for paying 35million for Andy Carroll, 20m for Stewart Downing and 16m for Jordan Henderson.

For a club crying out for good PR this year after the furore over Luis Suarez, the dreadful results and the poor performances of the club’s expensive recruits, to announce Comolli’s axing on Thursday was remarkable.

Just when Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard was speaking eloquently and passionately about a date with Everton in the FA Cup semi-final, saying that this game was ‘not going to be an ordinary semi-final’, another storm erupted.

‘We have a strategy we need implemented and we felt Damien was probably not the right person to implement that strategy,’ said Werner, his acerbic words sounding like a huge volte face from those offered by Henry six months ago.

‘We prefer stability. But when it’s time to act, we need to act. We’re coming close to the end of the season and the transfer window for the summer and we felt it was important to make this change expeditiously.’

Axed: Comolli paid the price for Liverpool's failings

Axed: Comolli paid the price for Liverpool's failings

There it was in a nutshell. FSG did not trust Comolli to spend their money and as soon as they came to that decision he was gone.

But Comolli was not the only one. On Thursday morning, Dr Peter Brukner, the Australian who was brought in during the summer of 2010 as the club’s head of sports science and sports medicine to revolutionise that department, was also dispensed with.

When he arrived at the club, Brukner used to sit on the bench next to former manager Roy Hodgson but that privilege quickly disappeared after Kenny Dalglish returned and his methods were viewed with scepticism in certain quarters.

There was a sense that managing director Ian Ayre would also be surplus to requirements but Werner gave him a vote of confidence, describing him as being ‘outstanding’ in his role of raising revenue.

Despite that, it would be no shock if the purge resumes at a later date.
Will it include Dalglish Werner declared not but the Scot will still need to provide written reasons at the end of the campaign to explain Liverpool’s erratic results, and the manner in which Comolli was jettisoned will serve as a reminder that FSG are single-minded when arriving at a decision.