Manchester City"s Champions League dream is over but Roberto Mancini"s job is safe

Ian Ladyman: Conquering Europe can wait, Roberto… just make sure you win the league to earn another shot at glory

|

UPDATED:

14:13 GMT, 25 October 2012

The American actor and director Woody Allen once described a relationship as being like a shark. ‘If it stops moving forward then it dies,’ he said.

Roberto Mancini sees a football team the same way. He believes in constant improvement and regeneration, especially when one of his teams has just won something. Standing still is, in the Italian’s mind, effectively the same as moving backwards.

No wonder, then, that Mancini looked so hollow-eyed as he left the Amsterdam Arena late on Wednesday night. To continue the shark analogy, he had just seen his team chewed up by one of European football’s smaller fish.

The morning after the night before: Mancini emerges from a coffee shop in Alderley Edge, Cheshire on Thursday

The morning after the night before: Mancini emerges from a coffee shop in Alderley Edge on Thursday

Mancini takes defeat badly. There will be much debate about his tactics. Rightly so. As he shuffled players late in the game, he appeared – rarely for him – like a manager who wasn’t totally sure what he was doing.

Micah Richards’ subsequent revelation that City had not practiced certain things they were asked to do left Mancini looking foolish.

In his mind, the tactics are not the major problem. He feels they haven’t changed greatly since last season’s title-winning campaign.

Down and (almost) out: Mancini (below) couldn't bare to watch as his City side slipped to defeat in Holland

Down and (almost) out: Mancini (below) couldn't bare to watch as his City side slipped to defeat in Holland

Down and (almost) out: Mancini (below) couldn't bare to watch as his City side slipped to defeat in Holland

His suggestion that defeat was down to his own poor preparation was a clumsy attempt to shield his players from blame. He has tried this before, after City lost at Everton back in January. He didn’t mean it then and he certainly doesn’t mean it now.

What does concern him, and what has done since the closing of the summer trading window, is that he hasn’t been able to move his team forward sufficiently.

In Amsterdam, Mancini’s starting XI contained not a single new player. Injuries deprived him of Javier Garcia – who would have played – and Maicon and Jack Rodwell.

Two other summer arrivals, Scott Sinclair – who hasn’t played a minute since the Capital One Cup defeat to Aston Villa last month – and young defender Matija Nastasic – who was not 100 per cent fit – were on the substitutes’ bench.

Buying expensive players is not necessarily the answer, of course. Nevertheless, Mancini remains irritated that his club didn’t bring him the A-list players he asked for back in May.

Ahead of Saturday’s engagement at home to Swansea, Mancini knows he has some morale to repair.

James Milner’s decision to walk straight past his manager but rather deliberately shake hands with every single player on the bench in Amsterdam may have looked rather petulant but also served to reinforce what we already know, namely that there is no great love between Mancini and his squad.

Off the boil: Lescott and Kompany have failed to emulate their heroics of last season

Off the boil: Lescott and Kompany have failed to emulate their heroics of last season

This does not trouble him. Mancini – as those close to him will tell you – is not in Manchester to make friends. He only has about five really close allies in the world and a confidante once told me: ‘If you are not in his team he will hardly speak to you. You may as well be dead.’

In Wednesday’s post-match press conference, Mancini referred to his players as millionaires. It sounded deliberately disparaging but wasn’t.

Certainly, Mancini is losing faith in Joleon Lescott and knows his captain Vincent Kompany is not at last season’s level. He refuses to blame his new defensive coach Angelo Gregucci – who speaks hardly any English.

Dutch of class: Ajax celebrate their win over the Premier League champions

Dutch of class: Ajax celebrate their win over the Premier League champions

One thing he does know is that his team must improve at the back very quickly. City have kept just one clean sheet this season. This time last year that figure stood at five. On the back of this, City’s Champions League season is all but over already.

But as long as City keep winning in the Premier League, there will be no threat to Mancini’s position. In Europe there is always next season.

Read the Ian Ladyman’s feature in full in Friday's Daily Mail

Euro 2012: Slaven Bilic backs Luka Modric to shine again as Croatia get set for Ireland

Bilic backs 'senator' Modric to lay down the law at Euro 2012 as Croatia get set for Ireland

|

UPDATED:

20:08 GMT, 9 June 2012

On his first managerial assignment with Croatia Under 21s, Slaven Bilic noted two of his little-known youngsters, Luka Modric and Vedran Corluka, hiding by the team bus when given free time to explore the beautiful Swedish city of Gothenburg.

Bilic instinctively knew why. He then asked the Croatia FA to give the penniless players a little spending money, to go into town, order coffee and chat to Swedish people of their generation. It is Bilic’s belief that players given confidence off the pitch will take responsibility in big matches.

Under his tutelage, Tottenham’s Modric has been transformed from an introverted child refugee from the Balkans conflict into a self-assured superstar, coveted by Manchester United and his country’s main hope in their first Euro 2012 group game against the Republic of Ireland in Poznan.

Focal figure: Luka Modric (bottom) makes Croatia tick

Focal figure: Luka Modric (bottom) makes Croatia tick

The tournament marks the end of Bilic’s successful six-year spell as Croatia manager with a lucrative post at Lokomotiv Moscow to follow. Famously, he allowed his players to go shopping and sightseeing on the morning of a key Euro 2008 qualifier against England at Wembley. Croatia’s 3-2 win cost the England manager Steve McClaren his job.

It came to symbolise Bilic’s relaxed approach to management and a repeat of Croatia’s quarter-final appearance at Euro 2008 could see them facing England or France, managed by Laurent Blanc, controversially sent off for pushing Bilic in the 1998 World Cup semi-final. Before then, the key to Croatia qualifying from a difficult group that includes Spain and Italy is whether Bilic can coax the best out of Tottenham maestro Modric after a testing season.

Close: Modric and Slaven Bilic

Close: Modric and Slaven Bilic

‘I told Luka before Euro 2008 that there were better-known midfield players in the tournament but, for me, he was the best. I told him that and he played great,’ said the coach, 43.

‘I expect the same now. I wouldn’t swap him for any midfielder, no way. Xavi and Iniesta have more trophies but Luka is in that category. It’s been a hard season after the pressure of transfer speculation. He played well but then had a few dodgy games like the rest of the Spurs team.

'There was never any rotation with Luka, he was too important. Luka has to cope with the pressure of being our star man, and he can. We have prepared him physically and psychologically. He was young at Euro 2008. Now he’s one of our senators.’

England v West Indies – day three, third Test, Edgbaston

LIVE: England v West Indies – the action on day three of the third Test at Edgbaston

|

UPDATED:

11:01 GMT, 9 June 2012

Stay up to date with all the action on day three of the third Test between England and the West Indies with Sportsmail's unrivalled team. We'll deliver over-by-over coverage as the action unfolds at Edgbaston while our team of writers will update with their insights from the ground. Email your thoughts to tom.bellwood@dailymail.co.uk

England v West Indies: Essentials

ENGLAND: Andrew Strauss, Alastair Cook, Jonathan Trott, Kevin Pietersen, Ian Bell, Jonny Bairstow, Matt Prior (wk), Tim Bresnan, Graeme Swann, Steven Finn, Graham Onions.

WEST INDIES: Adrian Barath, Kieran Powell, Assad Fudadin, Darren Bravo, Narsingh Deonarine, Marlon Samuels, Denesh Ramdin (wk), Darren Sammy, Tino Best, Ravi Rampaul, Sunil Narine.

Umpires: Kumar Dharmasena (SL) and Tony Hill (NZ).

DM.has('rcp',”twitterCombined”,
feeds : 'newman_cricket, the_topspin',
tweetCount : 4
);

Cricket writers on Twitter

Twitter Avatar

Loading tweets…

Feeds provided by Twitter

14th over: West Indies 31-0 (Barath 8, Powell 16)

One from Onions' over. And it's time for drinks. Given the weather, i imagine the players will want a cup of tea/coffee and pour it into their socks to warm up their frozen tootsies.

13th over: West Indies 30-0 (Barath 8, Powell 16)

It's fancy dress day at Edgbaston. Can't stand it myself. I'm no snob, just you put all that effort in, receive a little laugh and then have to spend the rest of the day looking like a plum. Bah hambug, etc. Two singles from Finn's over.

12th over: West Indies 28-0 (Barath 7, Powell 15)

Powell dabs the ball between third slip and gully, Jonny Bairstow gives chase and stops it just shy of the boundary courtesy of an athletic dive… much to the crowd's delight. That's the third three of the morning thus far – proving just how much moisture there is in the outfield.

11th over: West Indies 25-0 (Barath 7, Powell 12)

Edgbaston have shifted 17,000 tickets for today's play, a decent crowd and they are all wrapped up warm against the chilly conditions. A two jumper day. Or jumper and jacket combo required to combat the chilly weather. Not a day to be spent mooching around fine leg trying to keep the blood flowing through your fingers. Powell pushes back down the ground for three.

10th over: West Indies 21-0 (Barath 7, Powell 9)

Review! Graham Onions changes ends and very nearly makes the breakthrough. Brath is beaten by one which nips back in at him. there's a huge appeal but umpire Tony Hill shakes his head. Strauss take it upstairs but the ball is only clipping the top of the off bail. Decision stays with the on-field umpire and England lose a review. The first runs are added in five overs: Four leg byes and two for Barath through midwicket.

9th over: West Indies 15-0 (Barath 5, Powell 9)

First bowling change of the morning. Here comes Steven Finn to bang it into the track, Onions makes way. More talk of how good the bowling track remains. 'The groundstaff were working right through the night', chimes Sir Beef. It's a good start for Finn who keeps Powell back in his crease, watching successive deliveries slide wide of his off stump. Maiden.

8th over: West Indies 15-0 (Barath 5, Powell 9)

There's another six deliveries without a run. Maiden for Bresnan.

7th over: West Indies 15-0 (Barath 5, Powell 9)

Another maiden. Onions looks anguished as – for a split second – he thinks he's trapped Barath lbw. But there was an inside edge. If you have anything you would like to share today, my email address is at the top of the page. Anything you like. Recent test results. Bank account details. S'up to you.

6th over: West Indies 15-0 (Barath 5, Powell 9)

Dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, dot. That's a maiden over for Bresnan.

5th over: West Indies 15-0 (Barath 5, Powell 9)

Dropped! After a rather mundane opening spell, it finally starts to happen for Onions. But Ian Bell can't take the catch at third slip. The delivery pitches on off, jags away enough to take Barath's outside edge… but the chance was shelled. Bell is Jimmy Anderson's replacement in the slip cordon, by the way. Just saying.

Dropped: Bell looks rueful after shelling a decent chance at third slip

Dropped: Bell looks rueful after shelling a decent chance at third slip

4th over: West Indies 14-0 (Barath 4, Powell 9)

Howizaaaaaaaaaaaaat! Bresnan goes on a one-man appeal after he believes Powell has edged behind. The umpire shakes his head, the slip cordon stare at their feet, avoiding eye contact with the bowler. Powell finds his revenge with the following delivery which is thumped back down the ground, through the sluggish outfield for four more.

3rd over: West Indies 10-0 (Barath 4, Powell 5)

Shot! Onions dips one in full on off stump which is punched through mid-off by Powell. Finn sprints into action and just cuts the ball off from going for four. Credit to the West indies who are happy to play their shots in these early exchanges.

2nd over: West Indies 7-0 (Barath 4, Powell 2)

And here's Tim Bresnan to join Onions in the attack… but forget the details, Barath starts the over with a stunning flash through cover. Bresnan's first delivery was a touch full and dispatched to the rope in the flash of an eye. Four runs!

1st over: West Indies 3-0 (Barath 0, Powell 2)

'An unpleasant day for cricket. Blustery and very cold', enthuses Michael Atherton. Credit to the 17,000 fans who have paid their money to watch the action today, the chaps at Edgbaston will be happy when we reach the 25 over mark and they will no longer be liable for yet more refunds. graham onions it is who opens the attack, he slides one onto Barath's hips for a leg bye and Powell pushes a couple towards cover.

10.56: Players and officials are making their way out on to the pitch. Looks like we'll have some cricket presently. Hurrah!

10.53: We have – at best – three day's play to look forward to in Birmingham, but Bumble is in bullish mood. 'England have a fantastic chance of winning this, given the conditions'.

10.50: Ticket news from the chaps at Edgbaston: 'Everyone who buys a ticket from today or already had purchased a ticket for day four will receive a complimentary ticket for day five.'

10.48: Andrew Strauss sported a huge grin as he announced England would have a bowl. And why not

The covers have been firmly ensconced over the square for two days, plenty of juice in the track for Tim Bresnan and Graham Onions to swing it. Although Steven Finn may be asked to open the attack. Darren Sammy looked rueful, he says he would have taken the cherry this morning, too.

In a spin: Andrew Strauss wins the toss and elects to bowl

In a spin: Andrew Strauss wins the toss and elects to bowl

10.42: We knew about Jimmy, had an inkling Broad would be rested, too. But look at all those changes in the Windies' team. Four changes in total; debuts for Fudadin and Narine, plus 'Mind the Windows' Tino Best and Narsingh Deonarine are back.

10.35: BREAKING NEWS: England have won the toss and elected to bowl. Two changes to the team: James Anderson and Stuart Broad are out for Graham Onions and Steven Finn.

10.34: It was, in fact, the worst weather to blight a Test match since 1964. No lie. Credit to all the ground staff at Edgbaston that we have a playing surface ready for action.

10.30am: Morning all and welcome to Sportsmail's coverage on day three of the third Test. An incredible 80mm of rain over the last two days has put the kybosh on the action thus far but I can reveal (drum roll) we will be off and on time this morning. Super.

We're expecting more team changes as the captains allow frontline bowlers and batsmen a rest and hand those on the peripheries a chance.

The bad news which follows the good news of today's weather is that days four and five look just as rank as the opening two. Today could be our only chance to force a result!

Let's enjoy it while we can. News of the toss is imminent and the action will be underway from 11am.

Saturated: Edgbaston was rain-soaked once more on day two

Saturated: Edgbaston was rain-soaked once more on day two

Saturated: Edgbaston was rain-soaked once more on day two

Liverpool have not offered Roberto Martinez job

Liverpool mystified by Whelan's claim Martinez has been offered Anfield job

|

UPDATED:

21:30 GMT, 25 May 2012

Liverpool are no closer to making Roberto Martinez their new manager despite Dave Whelan claiming the Wigan boss has been offered a deal.

Martinez met Liverpool’s Principal owner John W Henry in Miami on Thursday for talks and that prompted Wigan chairman Whelan to declare on Friday that an offer has been made.

‘In the meeting, I think they made him an offer,’ said Whelan, who has set a deadline of next Thursday for Martinez to inform him of his intentions.

Walk this way: Roberto Martinez enjoys a coffee break with John Henry

Walk this way: Roberto Martinez enjoys a coffee break with John Henry

‘Roberto has asked what his responsibilities are because they are American owners and the rules and regulations they set down are a little bit different to what we English set down for football.’ Whelan also suggested Martinez will hold more talks with Fenway Sports Group next Tuesday but Liverpool are mystified by Whelan’s pronouncements.

Liverpool maintain their recruitment process is continuing and that means candidates such as Swansea boss Brendan Rodgers remain firmly in the frame to succeed Kenny Dalglish. Former Bayern Munich manager Louis van Gaal is in line for the position of Liverpool’s Sporting Director.

In the frame: Martinez has emerged as the front-runner to succeed Kenny Dalglish

In the frame: Martinez has emerged as the front-runner to succeed Kenny Dalglish

Martinez is very much in demand and is also now the clear favourite to land the Aston Villa job.

Villa have not offered the job yet to the Spaniard, despite holding talks with Martinez’s agents on Thursday, but he was owner Randy Lerner's first choice 12 months ago.

Roberto Martinez offered Liverpool job – Dave Whelan

Martinez to hold further talks with Liverpool but Whelan claims offer has been made

|

UPDATED:

15:08 GMT, 25 May 2012

Wigan chairman Dave Whelan claims manager Roberto Martinez has been made an offer by managerless Liverpool but will await a further meeting before making his decision.

The Latics boss met with Liverpool's principal owner John Henry in Miami on Thursday to talk about the vacant Anfield job after interrupting a family holiday in the Caribbean.

It was expected Fenway Sports Group would speak to other candidates on a short-list in the coming days but Whelan suggested developments had progressed.

Walk this way: Roberto Martinez enjoys a coffee break with Liverpool owner John Henry in Miami

Walk this way: Roberto Martinez enjoys a coffee break with Liverpool owner John Henry in Miami

Talks: Roberto Martinez is in Miami talking to Liverpool's owners about the current managerial vacancy at Anfield

He did, however, say Martinez – who would be expected to work under a technical director – wanted to negotiate a greater degree of control of footballing issues.

'I think what he has said is, “Thank you for your offer but I only work under the following rules: I have to have complete control of football”', Whelan told Sky Sports News.

'That's normally the way in England, that's how we all work.

'I think they're considering his request and Roberto's considering their offer and they're going to talk again on Tuesday.

'Hopefully he stays with us but wherever he goes, he's 100% dedicated to that football club.'

Liverpool have declined to comment on Whelan's claims.

It was anticipated the process of finding a replacement for Kenny Dalglish would have picked up pace next week with Henry and chairman Tom Werner likely to travel to England.

In the frame: Wigan boss Martinez has emerged as the front-runner to succeed axed Kenny Dalglish

In the frame: Wigan boss Martinez has emerged as the front-runner to succeed axed Kenny Dalglish

Martinez remains the favourite with the bookmakers, although that could have something to do with the fact he is the only contender publicly confirmed as being in the running.

Former Porto and Chelsea boss Andre Villas-Boas appears to have dropped out of the reckoning but it has been reported the Reds have not ruled out a second approach for Swansea's Brendan Rodgers after he declined their initial invitation to open preliminary talks.

Whelan, who set his manager a deadline of June 5 to decide his future, said yesterday he was not convinced Martinez would take the Liverpool job because of the structure under which he would be expected to work.

Former Wigan and Liverpool goalkeeper Chris Kirkland believes the Spaniard would regret not seizing the opportunity should it arise.

'What he'll be thinking to himself is: “Will I get this opportunity again”' said the 31-year-old, who had three seasons under Martinez at Wigan before agreeing a move to newly-promoted npower Championship side Sheffield Wednesday this week.

Kirkland added in the Wigan Evening Post: 'The Liverpool job is still one of the biggest in the world – and it doesn't get offered to you every day.

Looking ahead: Liverpool owner John Henry wants to find a suitable replacement for Dalglish

Looking ahead: Liverpool owner John Henry wants to find a suitable replacement for Dalglish

'It's a massive job and it will be a massive opportunity for somebody.

'Whether that will be Roberto remains to be seem.

'But my gut feeling is that he'll go – there's been too much speculation for far too long for something not to be happening.'

Martinez has failed to ignite the optimism of Liverpool fans, many of whom believe a more experienced manager should be tasked with getting the club back into the Champions League.

Former striker Peter Beardsley hopes the Spaniard, if appointed, will be able to win them over with his style of football.

However, the former England international believes FSG rushed into the decision to sack Dalglish after the club's eighth-placed finish this season.

'I think they panicked by getting rid of Dalglish,' Beardsley told talkSPORT.

'I think they should have given him another year and seen where it goes.

'But Roberto has done well at Swansea and Wigan, he's come through the system and his type of football will appeal to the Liverpool fans.'

Nike British 10k London run: Sportsmail"s Matt Lawless begins running journey

Hit the road, Matt… Sportsmail's man begins his journey ahead of British 10k Run

|

UPDATED:

10:43 GMT, 27 April 2012

Nike British 10k Run

Sportsmail's Matt Lawless has taken up the challenge of running the 2012 Nike 10k British Run.

Here, he will share the highs, lows, aches and pains of his training during the countdown to the big race in July.

How will he fare in what will be his first-ever competitive run

Keep track of Matt's progress at: www.dailymail.co.uk/sport

Running. I spend most of my life running. Running for the train. Running to pick my son up from school. Running errands, coffee run (sometimes)… you get the idea.

But never before have I run competitively (apparently, third place in the 100 metres at Warren Comprehensive School Sports Day in 2001 does not count).

That will change on Sunday, July 8, however, when I join 25,000 runners pounding the streets of London in the Nike 10k British Run.

Why Well, why not Truth be told, I needed an incentive to keep fit beyond the football season and that certainly wasn’t going to come in the form of spending three-and-a-half hours driving a buggy along a fairway, only to exit for brief (attempted) swings of a golf club.

Start me up: Sportsmail's Matt Lawless will join the runners competing in London on July 8

Start me up: Sportsmail's Matt Lawless will join the runners competing in London on July 8

Running, I’m told, is THE best way to keep in shape. ‘Brilliant, where do I sign up’ I asked the organisers. Hopefully, I won’t live to regret my unbounded enthusiasm.

I watched with genuine excitement as thousands crossed the line last weekend to complete the London Marathon. I imagined what it would be like to be soaking up the support from the pavement and pushing myself to the limit.

Certainly, 10k is no marathon. In fact, it’s around 20 miles less. Yet that’s still some distance for me to achieve. I’m a first-timer, after all.

But I can’t wait to experience that high of crossing the line and I’m ready for a challenging 10 weeks.

To kickstart my journey, I headed into central London for a Gait Analysis session. According to the experts at NikeTown, Gait is the way in which we move our body from one point to another.

The analysis involves a 15-second recorded stint on the treadmill, running at a comfortable pace to assess the way in which you run.

Enlarge

Man with a plan: Training begins with a gentle run just under the midway point of 5km

Man with a plan: Training begins with a gentle run just under the midway point of 5km

Any abnormalities in the technique are highlighted in the debrief where, after the advisors have consulted the video evidence, the right footwear is selected to help the runner avoid potential injury.

SHARE YOUR EXPERIENCE

If you’re taking part in the 10k British race and
a first time runner like me, I’d love to hear from you and share the
journey along the way before the main event.

And if you’re an experienced pacemaker, I’d be keen to hear your thoughts and advice too.

Stayed tuned for my next post in May.

I've done some research and read a few select running magazines recently to help understand what I’m getting myself into, and it appears Gait Analysis is a common – and recommended – practice for first-timers when choosing their trainers.

There’s much discussion surrounding the ‘Barefoot debate’ too (perhaps one to pick up on a later blog) but for now, to get started, I’m training with a cushioned sole to support my relatively untested feet.

I’ve had several short runs to ease me into a routine, but the hard work begins on Monday with a 5k jog – my furthest distance to date (please don’t laugh). My opening target time is 30 minutes.

For more on the Nike 10k British Run, go to: www.thebritish10klondon.co.uk
And for information on Nike Running, visit: www.facebook.com/NikeRunningUK

Manchester derby: Goal that still haunts Denis Law… 38 years on

The derby goal that still haunts United legend Denis Law… 38 years on

|

UPDATED:

22:43 GMT, 26 April 2012

On Monday night in Manchester, football will be the only thing that matters. City at home to United in a game that could well determine the destiny of this year's Barclays Premier League trophy.

With United leading City by three points but with an inferior goal difference, it's make-or-break time for the two sides ahead of what is being billed as the biggest Manchester derby since this month in 1974.

Back then, City travelled to Old Trafford knowing that a victory would send their great rivals down to the old Division Two.

As it turned out, former United hero Denis Law scored a famous back-heeled goal to give City a 1-0 win, though results elsewhere meant United would have been relegated anyway.

Sportsmail hears from six key men about that day.

What a heel: Denis Law (left) scores that famous goal in 1974

What a heel: Denis Law (left) scores that famous goal in 1974

DENIS LAW, City goalscorer

I just felt depressed, and that wasn't like me. After 19 years of trying my hardest to score goals, here was one that I almost wished hadn't actually gone in. I was inconsolable. I didn't want it to happen.

How long did the feeling last How long ago was the game Thirty-odd years. There is your answer.

The subject always crops up. It's one of those things. It's always there and I am always remembered for it. That's a shame.

I played with all those guys. They were pals. I didn't want them down. It was the last thing in the world that I wanted. It didn't feel good, no.

We weren't friends on the field. We would kick each other. But once the whistle went and it was over things changed. There was a bar in those days so we would have a cup of tea or coffee or a beer and then we might meet up later. It was just normal in those days.

I was a bit different as I had been at both clubs and I knew guys who were still playing. I knew the trainers and the guys behind the scenes. As the years have gone on it has changed, I guess.

MARTIN BUCHAN, United defender

Seventies flare-up: fans mob Law

Seventies flare-up: fans mob Law

I will never forget the look on Denis's face. That's etched on my mind and always will be. From our point of view, it was a scruffy goal. The pitch was dry and dusty – as they were in those days – and it just bobbled into the net. It was great execution from Denis, though, there is no getting away from that.

Afterwards we were very flat and empty. Relegation is a dreadful thing and the fact is we hadn't been good enough over the season. The fact that it was confirmed against our 'noisy neighbours' didn't make it any better but we didn't go down because of that game.

And we came back stronger in the end under Tommy Docherty and went on to play some great football so maybe the cloud did have a silver lining.

I would certainly say that Monday's game is the biggest since 1974. United have done incredibly well to get to where they are without players such as Nemanja Vidic.

It's great to see both teams at the top of the table but I won't try to predict what will happen. I was hopeless at doing that when I was a player so I won't do it now!

DENNIS TUEART, City forward

What made the rivalry so intense in 1974 was the number of local, North West players involved. On our side we had people like Colin Bell, Mike Summerbee, Glyn Pardoe and Mike Doyle and in the dressing room beforehand Doyle in particular was really winding us up.

I was new to the club and to the team but Mike made sure I knew what this meant. He was fiercely pro-Blue and anti-Red.

As we all know, Denis Law scored the winner and thought he had sent United down. In that moment you saw the two sides of his character. You saw the instinctive, goalscoring predator, the man who was a privilege to play with and train with and learn from. Then – when he realised what he had done – you saw the man himself, the gentleman who didn't want to hurt his old club. A sense of reality hit him.

They think it's all over: Fans invade the pitch and mob Law at the final whistle

They think it's all over: Fans invade the pitch and mob Law at the final whistle

Soon after there was a pitch invasion. Hordes of young fans with long hair, flares and stack-high boots poured on to the field and it looked a bit nasty. We went off and – because other results meant United were down anyway – we didn't come back on.

Afterwards our coach driver took us the long way back to Maine Road to get our cars. Every time he saw a Red he beeped his horn and the United fans were banging on the bus and making gestures. There were no blacked-out windows back then.

This game on Monday will be just as big. I still live in the area and I can tell you Manchester is bouncing. You would have to be blind and deaf not to understand what this game means.

Three wins and the title is City's. Who would have thought that

TOMMY BOOTH, City central defender

The most remarkable thing about the whole day in 1974 was that there was a 'do' arranged that night at Franny Lee's house and we all went. Some United players came along and, to his credit, Denis came too. That showed the type of man he was and still is.

LOU MACARI, United forward

It was my first derby in Manchester but I had come from Celtic so I was no stranger to big games. I also knew I had been bought because things weren't right with the team so I wasn't shocked to be in a relegation fight.

Lots of the players were indeed friends off the pitch but, let me tell you, we would all have done absolutely everything to win that game.

Winning start: Sir Alex in derbies

Denis got a good reception from the United fans before the game and that was only right. He had always conducted himself the right way. In the end his goal didn't actually relegate us. Other results did that.

The only parallel on Monday is Carlos Tevez but, no, he won't get a generous reception from United fans, will he He won't really understand – or perhaps even care – what the game means anyway.

Back then the lads lived locally and were always in town, eating or shopping. These days, apart from Mario Balotelli, it's almost impossible to spot a footballer in Manchester city centre.

Sir Alex Ferguson has called this game on Monday the biggest Manchester derby ever and he is probably right. Rarely, if ever, have both teams gone into a derby chasing the same prize.

City have the momentum but, remember, a draw would still virtually win the title for United. That's why the bookies rightly have them as favourites.

JOE CORRIGAN, City goalkeeper

I don't think Denis realised the significance of what he'd done. His instinct was just to put the ball in the net. I was at the Stretford End and I knew what was going to happen if we scored. The crowd invaded the pitch and I was surrounded within seconds.

A couple of policemen stood either side of me and said: 'We're beside you, the net's behind you. Just stay where you are and you'll be fine.'

Then I was escorted off the pitch inside a circle of police and we never went back on.