Scottish football fans handed community service after violent clash in retail park

Fans spared jail over violent clash between Dundee and Hamilton fans in retail park

By
Matt Coyle

PUBLISHED:

14:30 GMT, 23 April 2013

|

UPDATED:

16:36 GMT, 23 April 2013

A gang of hooligans who fought rival fans in a busy retail park as horrified families looked on escaped jail today.

The violent bust-up unfolded at New Douglas Retail Park in Hamilton, Lanarkshire, between supporters of Hamilton Academical and Dundee.

Two gangs of up to 30 'casuals' ran riot, battered each other and even spat at disgusted onlookers.

Shaun Murray, 27, Liam Fullerton, 18,
Daniel Weir, 21, Jamie Gilchrist, 29, all from Dundee, and Joseph
Roeves, 19, from Hamilton, were on trial at Hamilton Sheriff Court last
month.

Walking free: (left to right) Shaun Murray, Liam Fullerton, and Jamie Gilchrist must do community service

Walking free: (left to right) Shaun Murray, Liam Fullerton, and Jamie Gilchrist must do community service

They had denied fighting and causing fear and alarm on the day of a Scottish First Division match on December 3, 2011.

A jury found them guilty but on Tuesday they walked free from court after Sheriff Ray Small ordered each of them to perform 250 hours of unpaid work.

However he refused to hand down Football Banning Orders despite prosecutors asking for them to be imposed.

A 13-day trial had heard how shoppers and young children were forced to run into shops for cover as the violent encounter unfolded.

The gangs, who all dressed in casual clothes and wore no football colours, fought and launched bottles at each other. One innocent man who was with his young daughter was even spat at by one of the thugs.

Sales manager Sean Bicknell, 28, described how mayhem had erupted when the gangs clashed near Accies’ ground.

He
said: 'It was mayhem. I would describe it as a large scale disorder. It
wasn’t just one on one fights going on. It was four on one. My
impression was it was an organised event.'

Lyndsay Farrell, 31, from Motherwell, was shopping in the area at the time the fight broke out.

She told the court how she was forced to take cover in her car as the shocking incident spiralled out of control.

Scary scenes: The violence erupted at at New Douglas Retail Park in Hamilton, Lanarkshire

Scary scenes: The violence erupted at at New Douglas Retail Park in Hamilton, Lanarkshire

Miss Farrell said: 'I could see people in front of me who had a hold of one male. They were punching and kicking him and tried to drag him to the ground. A lot of them had bloody noses and things.'

Defence lawyers for all five men said the incident was out of character for them and only Roeves had a previous conviction.

Passing sentence, Sheriff Small said: 'We had to sit through a very lengthy trial about the activities and actions of the accused and particularly those who travelled from Dundee.

'I am in no doubt that those who travelled down got involved in a very unpleasant incident.

'I want to make it clear that if there was evidence that any of you had been personally involved in knocking anyone to the ground, throwing bottles or other violence you would be receiving a prison sentence.

'However it is unclear from the evidence whether you were directly involved in the disorder or were on the fringes but the fact you got involved means you deserve to be punished.

'I will impose a Community Payback Order of 250 hours to be completed over 12 months.'

Sheriff Small said he would tell Hamilton Accademical and Dundee FC of the convictions.

Ryan Devaney, 23, of Dundee had earlier walked free after the jury found the charge against him not proven.

Crystal Palace and Brighton fans fight: 10 arrests made

Ten arrests made after Brighton and Palace fans scrap in London

|

UPDATED:

17:31 GMT, 3 December 2012

Ten men arrested following a brawl between rival football fans have been released on bail.

Violence broke out between Brighton supporters and Crystal Palace fans in London after the npower Championship clubs were involved in separate fixtures on November 10.

A group of 10 men were questioned on suspicion of violent disorder this weekend and have been bailed until early January.

Scrap: Crystal Palace and Brighton fans clashed following the derby

Scrap: Crystal Palace and Brighton fans clashed following the derby

Four of the men were arrested in Sussex while six were held in Croydon and other parts of south London, Scotland Yard said.

Violence broke out in the King’s Cross area after Brighton drew 3-3 at Wolves and Palace secured a late 2-1 victory at Peterborough.

The arrests this weekend came as the rival clubs met each other in the league, at Palace’s Selhurst Park, in south London. The home side secured a 3-0 victory over their visitors who were reduced to 10 men in the first half.

Complaints: Brighton players moan to the referee during their thrashing

Complaints: Brighton players moan to the referee during their thrashing

The result – inspired by two goals from Palace’s former Brighton favourite Glenn Murray – sent the club to the top of the league.

Detective Chief Inspector Andy Barnes said police would seek football banning orders 'where appropriate'.

Chris Kirkland attack: Aaron Cawley charged with assault after drink binge

Jailed: Leeds thug handed four-month sentence for drunken attack on Kirkland… as court hears he downed 'cans of Stella, bottle of vodka and up to 10 pints of cider'

|

UPDATED:

12:53 GMT, 22 October 2012

Aaron Cawley – the fan who ran onto the pitch and attacked Chris Kirkland – has been jailed for four months after pleading guilty to assault and entering the field of play.

The 21-year-old, from Cheltenham, pleaded guilty to assault and invading the pitch during Sheffield Wednesday's home match against Leeds on Friday night.

Prosecutor Paul Macaulay said Cawley told police he was so drunk he could not remember the incident, which has been seen by millions of TV viewers.

Scroll down for video

Disgrace: The fan attacked Chris Kirkland

Disgrace: The fan caught Sheffield Wednesday keeper Chris Kirkland flush in the face with a sickening assault

Disgrace: The fan attacked Chris Kirkland

Disgrace: The fan attacked Chris Kirkland

VIDEO: Chris Kirkland is punched in the face by a fan…

DM.has('rcpv1913743414001','BCVideo');

Early years: Cawley - once a Leeds mascot - poses with Robbie Keane

Early years: Cawley – once a Leeds mascot – poses with Robbie Keane

Cawley, who appeared at Sheffield
Magistrates' Court, was arrested after Wednesday keeper Kirkland was
pushed in the face during the game at Hillsborough.

The incident was one of a number of ugly scenes at the Yorkshire derby, which ended in a 1-1 draw.

Kirkland, who has played for England, was shoved to the ground moments after conceding an equaliser in the 76th minute.

A man was clearly seen running from the Leeds fans onto the pitch and
pushing Kirkland in the face before running back into the crowd.
The incident was caught on camera by Sky Sports, which was broadcasting the game.

Unemployed labourer Cawley stood in the glass-fronted dock wearing a
blue T-shirt which left an 'LUFC' tattoo clearly visible on his neck and
a Leeds United club crest on his right arm.

The court heard that he had been the subject of two football banning orders in the past, which he had breached four times.

Despite living with his mother in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, he had
supported Leeds United all his life and went to every game – home and
away, a district judge was told.

District Judge Naomi Redhouse said she had not seen the footage and it was played for her in court on Monday.

Mr Macaulay said Cawley told officers he had drunk a number of cans of
Stella Artois lager on Friday morning, followed by three-quarters of a
litre of vodka – all before he got to Sheffield by train.

Once in Sheffield, he had a further seven to 10 pints of cider, the court heard.

District Judge Redhouse heard that Cawley, of Blenheim Square,
Cheltenham, only realised what he had done when other people told him
and then he saw himself clearly on TV.

He emailed the police to say sorry and also emailed Sky Sports in the
hope that his apology would be passed on to the two clubs and Kirkland.

Pain: Kirkland holds his face after the incident

Pain: Kirkland holds his face after the incident

His solicitor, Elizabeth Anderton, tried to tell the judge that reports
that her client had bragged about the incident in social networking
sites were wrong. But District Judge Redhouse stopped her, saying she
had not seen the reports and was not interested.

Mr Macaulay told the court the incident happened in about the 77th or 78th minute of the match.

Kirkland told police he had been already been hit by an object as he
warmed up in front of the Leeds United fans after coming out for the
beginning of the second half.

The Leeds fans were in the Leppings Lane end of the ground – the area where the Hillsborough disaster claimed 96 lives in 1989.

The prosecutor said Cawley came on to the pitch after Leeds scored and,
when he stood in front of Kirkland, the goalie thought it was someone
just 'excessively celebrating' or 'taking the mickey out of Mr
Kirkland'.

Mr Macauley described how Cawley then slapped the keeper on both sides of the face – hardest on the left-hand side.

Treatment: Leeds fans chant and jeer while Kirkland lies injured

Treatment: Leeds fans chant and jeer while Kirkland lies injured

He said Kirkland told police it was like he had been 'hit by a ton of bricks and went straight on the floor'.

The prosecutor said Kirkland was not seriously injured and Cawley was quickly identified as the perpetrator on the internet.

'This was not the most difficult police investigation,' Mr Macaulay said.

He added that Cawley was fully co-operative with the police but told
them he did not remember what happened after half-time because of his
drunken state.

He said he left the stadium before the end of the match and a steward
opened a gate for him to leave. Cawley told police he had been drinking
since 10am.

'He saw exactly what he had done on TV although he did not recall what he'd done,' Mr Macaulay said.

'He accepted it was clearly him on TV. He made email contact with South Yorkshire Police and Sky TV.'

The court heard that in the emails he said: 'It was a disgrace and I'm embarrassed by my actions.'

He said he had 'brought shame on Leeds United Football Club'.

Ripped down: A sign is torn from its berth at Hillsborough

Ripped down: A sign is torn from its berth at Hillsborough

The court heard that Cawley has a long history of football-related offending.

He was given a three-year football banning order in January 2008 at
Leeds Crown Court and another at Derby Magistrates' Court in November
2008 after breaches.

When he breached that order in September last year he was given 10 weeks in a Young Offenders' Institution.

The court was told that Kirkland made a Victim Impact Statement which said: “I feel shocked, upset and angry.

'I think the man is a thug and should be caught and put jail.

'Anyone who supports what he's done is just as bad.'

Today, Cawley admitted common assault and going on to a football pitch.

He was jailed for 16 weeks and ordered to pay 85 costs.

The district judge said he will be given a new banning order, probably
for five years, but the details of this will be sorted later.

Liverpool fan banning order for racist gesture at Patrice Evra

Liverpool fan banned after being caught on TV making racist gesture at United defender Evra

|

UPDATED:

16:47 GMT, 22 June 2012

Guilty: Phillip Gannon

Guilty: Liverpool fan Phillip Gannon

A Liverpool fan has been given a four-year football banning order after he was found guilty of racially abusing rival Manchester United supporters and their club captain Patrice Evra.

Phillip Gannon, 58, was seen on live television doing a racially offensive monkey impression, Liverpool Magistrates' Court was told.

The incident happened amid a volatile atmosphere at Anfield on January 28 this year when the two sides met in an FA Cup fourth round clash, Rob Girvan, prosecuting, told the court.

It was the first game between the Premier League rivals since an eight-match ban was imposed on Liverpool striker Luis Suarez after the FA found him guilty of racially abusing Evra.

In the 23rd minute of the game, the TV camera panned over fans in the lower Centenary Stand, where Gannon was sitting with two friends, and he was seen to position his hands under his armpits.

The coverage, broadcast worldwide by ITV, quickly spread across social networking site Twitter and complaints were made to police, the court heard.

Liverpool's Luis Suarez (R) challenges Manchester United's Patrice Evra

Volatile: Tension was high after race row involving Luis Suarez and Patrice Evra

Gannon, a carpenter and joiner from Heol Meirion, Barmouth, north Wales, was found guilty of two counts of using abusive or insulting words within the hearing or sight of a person likely to be caused alarm or distress.

The bench imposed a four-year banning order which stops Gannon from attending Liverpool and England games and also bans him from Liverpool city centre four hours before and after a match.

Gannon was also fined a total 180 and ordered to pay prosecution costs of 300.

Football fan banned for racially abusing Didier Drogba

Football fan banned from stadiums for three years after raciallly abusing Drogba

|

UPDATED:

18:23 GMT, 2 May 2012

A football fan has been handed a three-year stadium ban after hurling racist abuse at Chelsea striker Didier Drogba.

Stephen Fitzwater was in the Chelsea stand watching the team take on Tottenham at Wembley in the FA Cup semi-final on April 15 when he was heard making a racially offensive comment towards the player.

Other supporters took offence and reported him to a steward, and the 55-year-old from Hartland Road in Isleworth, west London, was arrested by Scotland Yard's football intelligence unit.

Target: Didier Drogba was racially abused by a Chelsea fan

Target: Didier Drogba was racially abused by a Chelsea fan

He admitted racially aggravated abuse at Hendon Magistrates' Court in north-west London on Monday and was given a three-year football banning order preventing him from attending any regulated football match in the UK or abroad, Scotland Yard said.

A Chelsea Football Club spokesman said: 'Chelsea Football Club and the overwhelming majority of our fans abhor all forms of discrimination and believe they have no place in our club or our communities.

'We will be taking the strongest possible action against this individual, who has received a football banning order along with a lifetime ban from Chelsea Football Club.

'We would like to thank Chelsea fans for reporting this incident and others which occurred during the semi-final, as a result of which a number of persons have been banned for using racial and abusive language.'

Wigan hand 17 fans life bans after Bolton win

Wigan slap fans with life bans after Bolton victory is marred by flares

Wigan have banned more than a dozen fans as a result of incidents during last weekend's derby victory at Bolton.

A number of flares were set off in the Latics end at the Reebok Stadium and the club have responded by writing to 17 spectators, predominantly aged between 15 and 22, to inform them they are no longer welcome to attend matches.

'We were extremely disappointed by the behaviour of a small minority of spectators who tarnished what was a fantastic day for the club,' Wigan chief executive Jonathan Jackson said in a statement.

Trouble: Wigan fans set off flares as their side beat Bolton last weekend

Trouble: Wigan fans set off flares as their side beat Bolton last weekend

'We have worked closely with Greater Manchester Police who will be issuing official football banning orders on the majority of those arrested during the game.

'We wish to protect the image of Wigan Athletic as a family club and do not welcome those who seek to make trouble and endanger the safety of our supporters.'

The club, keen to maintain their record of good behaviour, say prior to Saturday's game only three Wigan fans had been arrested this season.

West Ham owners want peace Millwall

West Ham owners make peace plea as Millwall come calling at Upton Park

West Ham co-chairmen David Gold and David Sullivan have pleaded with fans not to cause trouble ahead of Saturday’s derby with Millwall.

Disgraceful scenes marred the last meeting between the sides at Upton Park during a Carling Cup clash in August 2009 and Gold and Sullivan warned of punishments should there be any repeat.

‘We would just like to remind any supporter with the intention of doing anything but enjoying the game they will face serious consequences and will be dealt with in accordance with our matchday policies in conjunction with the Metropolitan Police,’ they wrote.

Flashpoint: West Ham and Millwall fans clashed at Upton Park in 2009

Flashpoint: West Ham and Millwall fans clashed at Upton Park in 2009

‘Previous incidents have seen nine season-ticket holders having their season tickets cancelled without refund and also received life bans from the club.

‘Fifty known supporters received life bans and most of those either received a three- or four-year football banning order.

‘This is your club; please show it the respect it deserves on the day, show your world-famous support and make it a day to be remembered for all the right reasons.’