Scotland 17 France 23: Brave show from Robinson's boys but Les Bleus roll on
Valiant Scotland remain in search of a first win of the 2012 RBS 6 Nations after Rugby World Cup finalists France earned a narrow victory in Edinburgh.
Murrayfield was given a glimpse of Scotland's potential, but the hosts fell short once more as Les Bleus clawed back an early 10-0 deficit and responded swiftly to going 17-13 down midway through the second half to triumph.
Scotland, who lost to England and Wales earlier this month, have beaten France once in 13 attempts in Six Nations competition – in 2006 – and have now lost five successive Test matches for the first time since 2004, when they finished with the Wooden Spoon.
We're not feeling Bleu: Wesley Fofana is mobbed by team-mates during the win over Scotland
SCOTLAND: Hogg, R. Lamont, S. Lamont, Morrison, Jones, Laidlaw, Blair, Jacobsen, Ford, Cross, Gray, Hamilton, Barclay, Rennie, Denton.
Replacements: De Luca for R. Lamont (31), Weir for Laidlaw (48), Cusiter for Blair (31), S. Lawson for Ford (69), Kalman for Cross (62), Kellock for Hamilton (69), Vernon for Denton (53).
Tries: Hogg, Jones. Cons: Laidlaw, Weir. Pens: Laidlaw.
FRANCE: Medard, Clerc, Rougerie, Fofana, Malzieu, Trinh-Duc, Parra, Poux, Szarzewski, Mas, Pape, Maestri, Dusautoir, Harinordoquy, Picamoles.
Replacements: Beauxis for Medard (62), Dupuy for Parra (75), Debaty for Poux (51), Servat for Szarzewski (51), Nallet for Maestri (66), Bonnaire for Picamoles (58). Not Used: Mermoz.
Tries: Fofana, Medard. Cons: Pape, Parra. Pens: Parra 2. Drop Goals: Beauxis.
Referee: Wayne Barnes (RFU).
It is a record which will lead to
further conjecture over the future of head coach Andy Robinson – now
with two wins from 13 Six Nations fixtures in charge – but there were
further illustrations of why the former England boss retains belief in
Stuart Hogg and Lee Jones scored
their first Test tries, Greig Laidlaw kicked five points and Duncan Weir
two, while the forward pack – as demanded by Robinson – went toe-to-toe
with a formidable French unit.
Ultimately the class of France, who
meet Ireland, England and Wales in the next three weeks, told as Wesley
Fofana and Maxime Medard scored tries, Morgan Parra kicked two
conversions and two penalties and Lionel Beauxis a drop goal.
There were mitigating factors in the defeat – Rory Lamont suffered an apparently serious knee injury,
Mike Blair a dead leg and Laidlaw a head injury – but it does not hide
the fact that unless victory in Dublin is claimed in two weeks' time,
Scotland could be facing a Wooden Spoon decider in Italy on the final
day of the championship.
Recently-retired duo Nathan Hines and
Dan Parks presented the match ball, but it was the new generation who
were facing the team second only to New Zealand at the World Cup.
Hogg, making his first Test start as
one of four changes from the side which lost 27-13 to Wales, had been
denied a try on debut in Cardiff but there was no doubt about his effort
in the corner after eight minutes.
Laidlaw, who missed an early penalty,
switched the play, and found Jones, who sent over Hogg, the 19-year-old
Glasgow Warriors full-back who recently discovered he is related to
It was just reward for a purposeful opening and Laidlaw converted.
Blair sparked another attack but
lacked support, before Ross Rennie halted a promising French foray
forward by stripping the ball from Imanol Harinordoquy.
Making a break: Scotland prop Ross Ford makes a a run during the RBS Six Nations match against France
Scotland were given a reminder of the
danger of France when Blair and Jones lost possession inside the
visitors' 22 and Medard picked up, before sprinting into the hosts'
The France full-back found Vincent
Clerc, who kicked, but was hauled down by Hogg and Medard was beaten to
the ball by Sean Lamont.
France transgressed following a Ross Ford burst and Laidlaw kicked the hosts into a 10-0 lead after 26 minutes.
Going over: Wesley Fofana scores for France
But moments later, the advantage was trimmed to three points.
Francois Trinh-Duc broke through an
attempted tackle from opposite number Laidlaw and the ball was recycled
quickly, with Clerc's sleight of hand finding Fofana, who evaded three
would-be tacklers to finish clinically. Parra converted.
Scotland suffered two further blows,
with the loss of Rory Lamont, who landed awkwardly challenging for the
restart, and Blair. Nick De Luca and Chris Cusiter came on.
Big tackle: Scotland's Rory Lamont takes down France's Wesley Fofana
Parra levelled the scores after
Scotland pulled down a maul but missed the chance to give Les Bleus an
interval lead by sending another penalty wide.
The scrum-half put France in front
for the first time early in the second half before Laidlaw was replaced
by Weir, who made his debut.
The pace of the game decreased with numerous substitutions taking place.
Worrying signs: Rory Lamont receives oxygen after sustaining an injury
John Barclay was the catalyst for Scotland reclaiming the lead.
The flanker made a sensational tackle and steal to feed De Luca, who fed fellow replacement Richie Vernon.
Vernon drew the defender and found Jones to touch down and Weir converted.
Power play: France's captain Thierry Dusautoir runs with a ball
The four-point advantage was
short-lived as France wing Julien Malzieu trampled over Jones and fed
Medard to score. Parra converted for a three-point lead with 20 minutes
France's defence remained stern and the visitors continued to sap the energy from their opponents as they moved down field.
Flying tackle: John Barclay of Scotland is tackled by Aurelien Rougerie
Thierry Dusautoir led the way into
the Scotland 22 and France teed-up Beauxis for a successful drop-goal
which stretched the lead to six points.
Beauxis dragged a late penalty wide, but France celebrated a second win of the tournament.