Carlisle leaps to Ferdinand's defence after United defender snubs Kick It Out campaign
12:52 GMT, 21 October 2012
The players' union have defended Rio Ferdinand's right to make a personal protest against the Kick It Out anti-racism campaign after Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson threatened to take action against the player.
Ferdinand, whose brother Anton was the subject of racist abuse from Chelsea captain John Terry last year, did not wear a campaign t-shirt in the warm-up to United's Barclays Premier League match against Stoke on Saturday despite Ferguson saying on Friday that all his players would.
Ferguson described the incident as 'embarrassing' and promised to 'deal with it'.
It is difficult to see what financial sanction could be imposed on Ferdinand in such circumstances, which instead points to a private dressing down for undermining Ferguson's authority.
In the red: Rio Ferdinand did not wear the Kick It Out t-shirt on Saturday
However, Professional Footballers Association chairman Clarke Carlisle told BBC Radio 5 Live: 'We will definitely monitor the situation very closely and make sure Rio Ferdinand's rights as a human being, never mind as a footballer, are not undermined in this position.
'Everyone has a right to free speech – just like you can't coerce anyone into shaking hands, you can't make somebody wear a T-shirt – although I do personally believe that joining in with the campaign is the best way forward.
'And then for all these players to get together and put what it is they want down on paper so we together as a union – all the players, one with another – can make those changes and move forward.'
The former Burnley player believes communication is key and urged Ferguson to follow the examples of Reading boss Brian McDermott and Newcastle manager Alan Pardew in allowing Ferdinand to explain the reasons behind his decision.
Standing his ground: Jason Roberts was among those refusing to take part
It was the declaration of Reading
striker Jason Roberts on Thursday that he would not be wearing a Kick It
Out shirt after becoming frustrated by what he perceived as the group's
lack of action over racism that earned a rebuke from Ferguson.
Carlisle added: 'There are two sides to this one.
'First of all, Sir Alex Ferguson is continual in his unwavering support for the Kick It Out campaign which is commendable and what we all want to see but you can't vilify or coerce any individual for making a stand.
'This shouldn't be seen as an element of control or defiance – just like Sir Alex Ferguson said when he was talking about Jason Roberts in his first interview, he doesn't know the reasons why this stand is being made and what we should do first of all is hear those reasons and listen to them and take them on board.
'Sir Alex Ferguson said he was embarrassed and that is because of the statement he had made but Brian McDermott and Alan Pardew, these guys said they had entered into dialogue with their players and listened to the reasons for them making their stand.
Furious: Sir Alex Ferguson
'So I would sincerely hope that Sir Alex Ferguson now speaks with Rio Ferdinand and asks him why he wanted to make that stand and hopefully supports the position he is in and it isn't seen as a player-against-manager situation.'
However, former Manchester United defender Viv Anderson believes Ferdinand was wrong to go against Ferguson.
Anderson, who became England's first black international when he played against Czechoslovakia in 1978, does not feel the United boss should have been put in such a position.
'I don't agree with Rio,' Anderson told MUTV.
'You can see the manager was fuming and clearly he didn't know anything about it.
'He expects his senior boys to set an example. He is the manager. If he says we are all doing it together, it should be the end of the story.
'But Rio has gone the other way.
'I don't see where he is coming from and I don't know what it is going to achieve.'